Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello


Compare What is it? Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
It is a pasta maker that creates different types of pastas automatically.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
This is the premium version of the famed Philips Pasta Maker and exclusive to Williams Sonoma.

KitchenAid
This is a three-piece Pasta Roller and Cutter Set that quickly and easily makes pasta right from scratch.

Lello
It is an electric pasta extruder that presses the pasta through the shaping discs, instead of rolling and cutting shapes like a cutter or roller.

 

Compare What does it Do? Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
You can make a pound of fresh pasta or noodles in less than 15 minutes with Philips Pasta Maker.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
The eight discs included in Philips Smart Pasta Maker create a number of pasta shapes, such as Angel Hair, Tagliatelle or Pappardelle.

KitchenAid
Instead of consuming pre-packaged pasta, making it fresh and tastier is easy with the KitchenAid Stand Mixer that makes fresh pasta from scratch.

Lello
By just choosing the ingredients, the fully-automatic and electric Lello Pastamaster kneads the dough and mixes it to make fresh, artisan-style pasta at home easily. It also extrudes the pasta and can make short shapes such as penne and macaroni.

 

Compare Accessories: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
The pasta maker comes with a measuring cup, cleaning tool, and recipe booklet.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
The kit of the machine includes eight shaping discs, two measuring cups for water and flour, flat cleaning or scraping tool, disc cleaning tools and recipe book.

KitchenAid
The pasta maker comes with one Pasta Roller, Fettuccine Cutter, Spaghetti Cutter, and Cleaning Brush each.

Lello
There are eight pasta discs, user guide, and 38 recipes.

 

Compare Features: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
The pasta maker features a detachable shaft. The LED display, Preset Cooking function, On/Off Switch, Power On Light, and Ready signal provide convenience of use. The pasta maker assures safety of use with Automatic shut-off, non-slip feet, and safety lock. The machine comes with a recipe book containing 24 different kinds and flavors of pasta and 20 noodles/pasta recipe dishes. The four default unique shaping discs create spaghetti, penne, fettuccini, and lasagna, with additional discs available for different kinds of pastas and noodles.
The specially-designed cleaning tools match the shapes of Spaghetti and Fettuccini discs and ensure cleaning is easy with a one-push action. All the shaping discs and cleaning tools can be stored in the storage drawer at the bottom. The advanced engineering, high-quality materials, and sturdy construction of the machine make it possible to make 0.5lb of perfectly textured and tasting pasta in approximately 10 minutes by exerting 1600 lb force on the dough while extruding.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
With the pasta maker it is possible to make 1lb fresh pasta within 15 minutes. The machine included eight discs. Philips Smart Pasta Maker has a fully automatic function for mixing, kneading and extruding the pasta. It automatically senses when the extrusion process needs to start. The auto-weighing function weighs flour and suggests the right amount of liquid to add for consistent results.

KitchenAid
The pasta maker, powered by KitchenAid® Stand Mixer, is a three-piece Pasta Roller and Cutter Set that makes fresh homemade pasta quickly and easily. It fits every household KitchenAid® Stand Mixer. The commercial style stainless steel construction of rollers and cutters ensures smooth rolling and neat cutting of the pasta dough. Eight thickness settings allows you to adjust sheets to your desired thickness as the pasta roller rolls six-inch sheets of pasta. You can cut the pasta sheets into spaghetti noodles with the Spaghetti Cutter of and fettuccini noodles with the Fettuccine Cutter. The chrome-plated steel construction ensures durability, as the attachments provide consistent results year after year. The wooden rush and toothpick cleaning set promise thorough cleaning of all three attachments.

Lello
It is one of the few electric pasta makers that can mix the dough and extrude it through the shaping discs. The models make up to three pounds fresh pasta in just 20 minutes. The machine can turn your favorite flours and add-ins into personalized pasta from spaghetti, macaroni, linguine, to capellini, automatically. In the long run, the cost of making pasta works out to be a fraction of the cost of fresh pasta bought at a store, especially that of gourmet and specialty pasta such as gluten-free. The possibility of making pasta is endless as Lello can also make colored theme pasta for occasions such as a Halloween party, Valentine’s Day, Christmas, and so on. Lello boasts of a sturdy construction and is well-rated by users.

 

Compare Wattage: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker and Philips Smart Pasta Maker have 200 W.

KitchenAid
Not found

Lowell
300 Watts

 

Compare Programs: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
2 Prefix programs

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
Not found

KitchenAid
Not found

Lello
Not found

 

Compare Discs: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
There are four default shaping discs for Fettuccini, Penne, Spaghetti, and Lasagna and more shaping are included as additional accessory for various kinds of noodles and pasta.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
The pasta maker has eight different discs for fettuccini, penne, lasagna/dumpling, spaghetti and thick spaghetti, angel hair, tagliatelle and pappardelle pastas.

KitchenAid
Three-Piece Pasta Roller and Cutter Set

Lello
8 pasta discs

 

Compare Dimensions: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
Length 343 x Width 215 x Height 300 mm

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
13½” x 8½” x 12½” high

KitchenAid
9.7 x 3.8 x 2.2 inches

Lello
12 x 8 x 12 inches

 

Compare Weight: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
7.5 kg

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
7.5 kg

KitchenAid
7.5 lbs

Lello
21 lbs

 

Compare Price: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker
$349.95

Philips Smart Pasta Maker
$349.95

KitchenAid
$249.99

Lello
$240.08

 

Compare Warranty: Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker and Philips Smart Pasta Maker have 2-year worldwide guarantee

KitchenAid
1-year manufacturer’s warranty

Lello
1-year limited warranty


 

Compare REVIEWS Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello

Philips Pasta Maker

Philips Pasta Maker review reveals that the machine very quickly broke the metal piece that extrudes the dough and there was no customer support from the manufacturer.

Philips Pasta Maker review complains that its Fettuccine shaper was defective. It was just a ball of plastic in the wheel that made the disc inoperable. The pasta maker was returned because its motor malfunctioned. It also doesn’t make pasta as delish as one would expect it to.

Philips Pasta Maker review exposes that it does not make good noodles that come out broken or stuck together. The electric pasta maker is overpriced especially because most of the noodles cannot be used. Even when the dough is made and extrusion only format is used, the dough does not extrude as it should. The flour comes out. The machine is not quite fully-automatic as it claims and one needs to do some handwork to get the pasta out.

Philips Pasta Maker review states that the dough recipes included in the instructions are very poor. When the instructions for the recipe were followed, the result was dry and flavorless pasta.

Philips Pasta Maker review says that often the dough extrudes inside and becomes very painful to clean up. All the parts needed soaking up in a tub of hot soapy water and could only be cleaned up the following morning. The measuring cups of Philips Pasta Maker were of no use. The machine struggles to push the pasta so hard that the metal plate pushes away from the unit. Then the machine cannot push the pasta at all.

Philips Pasta Maker review complains that the cleanup of the pasta maker is cumbersome and difficult. In fact, it is so unpleasant that the machine is not used anymore.

Philips Pasta Maker review calls it too expensive for its limited function. It cannot make wrappers for Chinese Dumplings as it is too firm and dry to hold the wrapper into one piece. This makes the pasta maker a noodle maker at best.

Philips Pasta Maker review advises to opt for the older and comparatively simpler model. This machine does not work and makes awful pasta. It is extremely disappointing. The review adds that the pasta maker is difficult to use, high-maintenance, unreliable, heavy, and does not measure accurately.

 

Philips Smart Pasta Maker

Philips Smart Pasta Maker review states that though the machine sounds great and simple to use and needs pouring the flour in, after which it weighs and gives exact liquid measurement. However, the glitch is that it makes the pasta too thick. Another shortcoming is that since you cannot regulate the ingredients, one needs to put in the exact amounts that the machine indicates for the machine to work. Even when different kinds of flours were tried, it yielded the same results. The hand crank and electric machines made in Italy give perfectly handcrafted dough. The ease and quickness of use of this machine is incredible. Other shortcomings include the fact that the machine does not have Asian noodle dies and is not available in the US, it does not have programmed rest period.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker review says that the recipe book should have had gluten-free versions. All the shape discs are not available in the US – for instance, Asian discs cannot be found in the US. It would have made more sense to have a Macaroni.disc instead of tagliatelle and papparadelle since that’s more common in the US. Also, no one needs to extrude cookies.

Philips Smart Pasta Maker review opines that it needs more disk options. It has long-drawn instructions, due to which index card with only the basics needs to be kept handy. In spite of being easy to clean, it has a number of bulky parts that makes it a tough job, because of which one wouldn’t make pasta as often as one would using packaged pasta. The machine churns out very thick out, especially fettuccine. It also does not give the optimal semolina, all purpose flour, egg, and water ratio.

 

KitchenAid

KitchenAid review says that it looks superior-quality and very heavy. It fits the mixer perfectly but is impossible to clean.

KitchenAid review complains that it did not function and does not give clean and dried up pasta. The accompanying brush fails to get all the pasta out. The pasta dries inside the pasta maker and one cannot open the machine up to clean it. The machine works well but does not clean well.

KitchenAid review calls it extremely expensive and difficult to use.

KitchenAid review exposes that it’s roller broke possibly because the dough was stuck inside the roller unit. It’s baffling how the dough gets into the unit, in the first place.

KitchenAid review states that as typical to KitchenAid appliances, this is very fancy, attractive, and performs well. Though the machine is satisfactory, it does not secure onto the mixer well. While the dough was being rolled, the attachment started spinning. The dough stuck to the rollers and consequently to its inner parts, which makes it difficult to clean. The adjusting mechanism is substandard considering it’s an expensive kitchen appliance.

KitchenAid review praises its superior-quality stainless materials that make cleanup easy even though the individual units cannot be detached.

KitchenAid review calls it expensive and difficult to use and it would probably not be used again.

KitchenAid review says that it makes pasta preparation very easy but the roller turned noisy and squeaked right after the first use. The rollers cannot get wet, which makes it difficult to clean.

KitchenAid review brings to light that its pitfall is that it cannot be washed and submerged, which makes it removal of excess dough difficult.

KitchenAid review says that it works quite well but cannot be cleaned in the dishwasher or be submerged in water.

KitchenAid review opines that making pasta considering the cost of this accessory turns out to be very expensive.

 

Lello

Lello review states that the instructions were followed perfectly and yet the machine mixed the ingredients shoddily and extruding was a terrible experience. The chamber didn’t take in enough dough to extrude to the die and make pasta, which is possibly a defect in the pasta maker. Even after working on it for many hours it gave a small amount of pasta.

Lello review complains that dough did not extrude properly even after seven attempts of making different kinds of pasta.

Lello review calls it a disappointment. The recipes were quite bad for the machine and turned out too gooey or too thick and there was not perfect medium consistency. The old school method of handmade pasta and cranking it through the cutter seemed more sensible. The traditional way is not as frustrating and works out much better than the pasta maker did.

Lello review cautions that this is a horrible machine for anyone who is new to homemade pasta. The pasta maker stopped working right during the first use and had to be returned. The hand crank machine with a motor on would in all likelihood be easier and fail-safe than Lello. The instructions also warn one that the pasta maker could malfunction if flour gets in past a specific part of the machine.

Lello review exposes that the machine broke on the second use. It is incomprehensible why plastic threads are used on a machine that has to withstand a lot of force.

Lello review calls it a useless gadget that wastes counter space for some time and then goes in the junk. Its alleged 3lb capacity does not work. The machine is very slow. If you want to extrude pasta, you need to remove a small plastic divider after the dough is mixed. On removing the divider, the opening for the dough brings out all the pasta on to the counter.

Lello review criticizes it for being very noisy and excruciatingly slow and it also a bit messy.

Lello review reveals that the machine is very loud and heavy. It also did not make the dough to a good consistency. The extrusion in the machine is extremely slow as well. To clean the machine, the pasta was left to dry on the parts. The dried pasta was then knocked off, which worked very well. The pasta maker is easy to use and the instructions are easy to follow.


Be the first to comment on "Philips Pasta Maker vs Philips Smart Pasta Maker vs KitchenAid vs Lello"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.